For the complete documentation index, see llms.txt. This page is also available as Markdown.

Torsional Analysis of Rigid Diaphragm Theory

Understand the theory for distributing lateral loads to resisting elements and locating the center of rigidity.

Introduction

The distribution of lateral loads in structures with rigid diaphragms and orthogonal crosswalls or frame systems is a well-established topic in structural engineering literature. In such systems, the total lateral displacement of a resisting element results from the combined effects of flexural and shear deformations. This document presents a unified design method that captures these behaviors using energy-based principles and stiffness matrix computations.

This document also demonstrates a computational approach to distributing lateral forces in multi-resisting element systems, considering diaphragm rotation and translation, using stiffness matrices and energy principles to determine element forces and the overall center of rigidity.

For definitions of variables and symbols used throughout, refer to the Notations section at the end of this document.

Resisting Element Local Stiffness

We begin by characterizing how each resisting element displaces under load. These displacements are used to build the element's flexibility matrix, which can then be inverted to produce the element’s local stiffness matrix.

The lateral displacement of a resisting element results from both bending and shear deformation. The total displacement δ\delta at the top of the element under a lateral load PP is expressed as δ=δf+δv\delta = \delta_f + \delta_v, where δf\delta_f is the displacement due to flexure, and δv\delta_v is the displacement due to shear. These lateral displacements also depend on the end fixity conditions.

Displacement Behavior of Wall Elements

For both ends fixed (i.e., restrained against rotation):

Fixed-Fixed: δ=δf+δv=Ph312EbI+βPhEvA\delta = \delta_f + \delta_v = \frac{Ph^3}{12E_bI} + \frac{\beta Ph}{E_vA} (1)

For one end fixed and the other end pinned:

Fixed-Pinned: δ=δf+δv=Ph33EbI+βPhEvA\delta = \delta_f + \delta_v = \frac{Ph^3}{3E_bI} + \frac{\beta Ph}{E_vA} (2)

Where β\beta, the shear correction factor, is given by:

β=AI2∫A(Qb)2dA\beta = \frac{A}{I^2} \int_A \left( \frac{Q}{b} \right)^2 dA (3)

For walls with rectangular cross sections, β\beta is equal to 1.2.

NOTE: The shear modulus EvE_v (sometimes also represented as GG) of cementitious materials is often estimated as Ev=0.4EbE_v=0.4 E_b. This estimate is provided as a convenience in the module but may be overridden with a user-defined value.

For concrete, ACI 318 does not formally define EvE_v, but it does present this as a reasonable approximation in Commentary R6.6.3.1

For masonry, TMS 402 includes the same approximation in Table 4.2.2.

Displacement Behavior of Bending Elements

For bending members, flexural deformation dominates the overall behavior, and shear effects can often be neglected. In these cases, displacement simplifies to the flexural component only:

Fixed-Fixed: δ=δf=Ph312EbI\delta = \delta_f = \frac{Ph^3}{12E_bI} (4)

Fixed-Pinned: δ=δf=Ph33EbI\delta = \delta_f = \frac{Ph^3}{3E_bI} (5)

Flexibility and Stiffness Matrices

Once the displacement δ\delta is known for a unit load along each of the elements primary local axes, the flexibility matrix [a]local[a]_{local} is formed:

[a]local=[δxxδxyδyxδyy]=[δxx00δyy][a]_{local} = \begin{bmatrix} \delta_{xx} & \delta_{xy} \\ \delta_{yx} & \delta_{yy} \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \delta_{xx} & 0 \\ 0 & \delta_{yy} \end{bmatrix} (6)

Where:

δxx\delta_{xx} = displacement along local 'x' in response to a unit force along local 'x'

δyy\delta_{yy} = displacement along local 'y' in response to a unit force along local 'y'

δxy=δyx=0\delta_{xy}=\delta_{yx}=0 due to decoupled behavior in orthogonal directions

To compute the local stiffness matrix, [k]local[k]_{local}, we can simply invert [a]local[a]_{local}. Since [a]local[a]_{local} is diagonal, this inversion is straightforward:

[k]local=[a]local−1=[1δxx001δyy]\boxed{ [k]_{local} = [a]_{local}^{-1} = \begin{bmatrix} \frac{1}{\delta_{xx}} & 0 \\ 0 & \frac{1}{\delta_{yy}} \end{bmatrix} } (7)

NOTE: In some cases, users may choose to neglect stiffness along the element’s weak axis, typically when its contribution to lateral resistance is insignificant or unconservative to include. When doing so, the corresponding direction in the local stiffness matrix is assigned a value of zero, effectively removing its influence from the overall system stiffness.

Resisting Element Global Stiffness and Force Transformation

Resisting elements are often oriented at angles relative to the global axes. While each element’s local stiffness matrix accurately captures its resistance along its own principal axes, these stiffness properties must be expressed in the global coordinate system before they can be combined with other elements contributing to the overall lateral stiffness.

To accomplish this, a transformation matrix is applied to rotate stiffness values from the element’s local coordinate system into the global coordinate system. For a resisting element rotated by an angle θ\theta (measured from the global x-axis to the element’s local x-axis), the rotation matrix [T][T] is defined as:

[T]=[cos⁡θsin⁡θ−sin⁡θcos⁡θ][T] = \begin{bmatrix} \cos\theta & \sin\theta \\ -\sin\theta & \cos\theta \end{bmatrix} (8)

NOTE: In this program, the rotation angle is typically defined as the angle from the global x-axis to the element’s local y-axis*, since the local y-axis is generally aligned with the element’s strong axis. For example, a wall with a rotation of 0 degrees is parallel to the global x-axis, and a rotation of 90 degrees is parallel to the global y-axis. However, the rotation matrix used for stiffness transformation requires the angle to be measured from the global x-axis to the element’s local* x-axis*. Therefore, when using the program-defined angle, it is necessary to subtract 90 degrees to obtain the correct orientation for the transformation matrix.*

The element global stiffness matrix [K][K] is then obtained from the element local stiffness matrix [k]local[k]_{local} through the following transformation:

[K]=[KxxKxyKyxKyy]=[T]T[k]local[T]\boxed{ [K] = \begin{bmatrix} K_{xx} & K_{xy} \\ K_{yx} & K_{yy} \end{bmatrix} = [T]^T [k]_{local} [T] } (9)

After the rigid diaphragm analysis is complete and elemental forces in the global system have been determined, the same transformation matrix can also used to convert these forces back into the element’s local coordinate system to find the strong and weak axis applied shear. For example, given global forces [F][F], the corresponding local forces [f]local[f]_{local} can be determined as:

[f]local=[T][F]\boxed{ [f]_{local} = [T] [F] } (10)

Where:

[f]local=[VxVy][f]_{local} = \begin{bmatrix} V_x \\ V_y \end{bmatrix}

[F]=[FxFy][F] = \begin{bmatrix} F_x \\ F_y \end{bmatrix}

Rigid Diaphragm Global Stiffness Matrix

We now turn to assembling the rigid diaphragm global stiffness matrix, which is formed by integrating the element global stiffness matrices into a single global stiffness matrix for the entire system.

Consider the displacements of the single wall assembly shown in Figure 1:

Figure 1: Element Rotation

The magnitude of the displacements are assumed to be very small. The assembly rotates through an angle Δθ\Delta_\theta (counter-clockwise positive) about the origin of coordinates X and Y, and translates Δx\Delta_x and Δy\Delta_y. The diaphragm is assumed to be very rigid compared to the walls. When the diaphragm rotates without translation, displacements occur which generate the following forces on the element:

Fx=KxxΔx+KxyΔyF_x = K_{xx}\Delta_x + K_{xy}\Delta_y (11)

Fy=KyxΔx+KyyΔyF_y = K_{yx}\Delta_x + K_{yy}\Delta_y (12)

Mz=JΔθM_z = J\Delta_\theta (13)

Mp=xFy−yFx+JΔθM_p = xF_y - yF_x + J\Delta_\theta (14)

Where:

KxyK_{xy} is the force in the X direction due to a unit displacement in the Y direction.

JJ is the rotational stiffness calculated as the moment about the Z axis due to a unit rotation of the element about the Z axis.

All values are plotted using the right-hand Cartesian coordinate axis system; thus a negative sign indicates a displacement in the negative direction or a clockwise moment. FzF_z, MxM_x, and MyM_y are zero for this type of system.

Using small-angle approximations, it can be shown that for the displacement in Figure 1:

Δx=−yΔθ,Δy=xΔθ\Delta_x = -y\Delta_\theta \quad , \quad \Delta_y = x\Delta_\theta

Thus, Equations 11, 12, and 14 can be revised as follows. It should also be noted that Kxy=KyxK_{xy} = K_{yx}. Therefore, all subsequent formulations will adopt KxyK_{xy} for consistency.

Fx=Kxx(−yΔθ)+Kxy(xΔθ)F_x = K_{xx}(-y\Delta_\theta) + K_{xy}(x\Delta_\theta ) (15)

Fy=Kxy(−yΔθ)+Kyy(xΔθ)F_y = K_{xy}(-y\Delta_\theta) + K_{yy}(x\Delta_\theta ) (16)

Mp=(x2Kyy+y2Kxx−2xyKxy+J)ΔθM_p = \left( x^2K_{yy} + y^2K_{xx} - 2xyK_{xy} + J \right)\Delta_\theta (17)

When the diaphragm translates without rotation (see Figure 2), displacements occur which generate the following forces on the element:

Fx=KxxΔx+KxyΔyF_x = K_{xx}\Delta_x + K_{xy}\Delta_y (18)

Fy=KxyΔx+KyyΔyF_y = K_{xy}\Delta_x + K_{yy}\Delta_y (19)

Figure 2: Element Translations

Equations 15 through 19 can then be combined to find the total element forces acting on the diaphragm when the diaphragm translates and rotates:

Fx=KxxΔx+KxyΔy+(xKxy−yKxx)ΔθF_x = K_{xx}\Delta_x + K_{xy}\Delta_y + (xK_{xy}-yK_{xx})\Delta_\theta (20)

Fy=KxyΔx+KyyΔy+(xKyy−yKxy)ΔθF_y = K_{xy}\Delta_x + K_{yy}\Delta_y + (xK_{yy}-yK_{xy})\Delta_\theta (21)

Mp=(x2Kyy+y2Kxx−2xyKxy+J)ΔθM_p = \left( x^2K_{yy} + y^2K_{xx} - 2xyK_{xy} + J \right)\Delta_\theta (22)

These equations may now be written in matrix notation:

[FxFyMp]=[KxxKxy(xKxy−yKxx)KxyKyy(xKyy−yKxy)00(x2Kyy+y2Kxx−2xyKxy+J)][ΔxΔyΔθ]\boxed{ \begin{bmatrix} F_x \\ F_y \\ M_p \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} K_{xx} & K_{xy} & (xK_{xy}-yK_{xx}) \\ K_{xy} & K_{yy} & (xK_{yy}-yK_{xy}) \\ 0 & 0 & (x^2K_{yy} + y^2K_{xx} - 2xyK_{xy} + J) \end{bmatrix} \begin{bmatrix} \Delta_x \\ \Delta_y \\ \Delta_\theta \end{bmatrix} } (23)

If the applied loads on the diaphragm are PxP_x and PyP_y in the X and Y directions, and a torsional moment TpT_p is also applied to the diaphragm in the positive, counter-clockwise direction:

ΣFx=0:Px=ΣFx\Sigma F_x = 0: \quad \quad \quad P_x = \Sigma F_x (24)

ΣFy=0:Py=ΣFy\Sigma F_y = 0: \quad \quad \quad P_y = \Sigma F_y (25)

ΣMz=0:Tp=ΣMp\Sigma M_z = 0: \quad \quad \quad T_p = \Sigma M_p (26)

Where:

ΣFx\Sigma F_x is the sum of all resisting element forces acting in the global X direction.

ΣFy\Sigma F_y is the sum of all resisting element forces acting in the global Y direction.

ΣMp\Sigma M_p is the sum of the torsional moments from all resisting element forces acting about the diaphragm center of rigidity.

Substituting the values from Equations 24, 25, and 26 into Equations 20, 21, and 22 yields:

Px=ΔxΣKxx+ΔyΣKxy+Δθ(ΣxKxy−ΣyKxx)P_x = \Delta_x\Sigma K_{xx} + \Delta_y\Sigma K_{xy} + \Delta_\theta (\Sigma xK_{xy} - \Sigma yK_{xx}) (27)

Py=ΔxΣKxy+ΔyΣKyy+Δθ(ΣxKyy−ΣyKxy)P_y = \Delta_x\Sigma K_{xy} + \Delta_y\Sigma K_{yy} + \Delta_\theta (\Sigma xK_{yy} - \Sigma yK_{xy}) (28)

Tp=Δθ(Σx2Kyy+Σy2Kxx−2ΣxyKxy+ΣJ)T_p = \Delta_\theta (\Sigma x^2K_{yy} + \Sigma y^2K_{xx} - 2\Sigma xyK_{xy} + \Sigma J) (29)

Again, these equations may now be written in matrix notation to describe the diaphragm's global force-displacement behavior:

[PxPyTp]=[ΣKxxΣKxy(ΣxKxy−ΣyKxx)ΣKxyΣKyy(ΣxKyy−ΣyKxy)00(Σx2Kyy+Σy2Kxx−2ΣxyKxy+ΣJ)][ΔxΔyΔθ]\boxed{ \begin{bmatrix} P_x \\ P_y \\ T_p \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} \Sigma K_{xx} & \Sigma K_{xy} & (\Sigma xK_{xy}-\Sigma yK_{xx}) \\ \Sigma K_{xy} & \Sigma K_{yy} & (\Sigma xK_{yy}-\Sigma yK_{xy}) \\ 0 & 0 & (\Sigma x^2K_{yy} + \Sigma y^2K_{xx} - 2\Sigma xyK_{xy} + \Sigma J) \end{bmatrix} \begin{bmatrix} \Delta_x \\ \Delta_y \\ \Delta_\theta \end{bmatrix} } (30)

Center of Rigidity

To find the center of rigidity, the following relationships must be true:

ΣxKxy−ΣyKxx=0\Sigma xK_{xy} - \Sigma yK_{xx} = 0 (31)

ΣxKyy−ΣyKxy=0\Sigma xK_{yy} - \Sigma yK_{xy} = 0 (32)

Then, Equations 27, 28, and 29 become:

Px=ΔxΣKxx+ΔyΣKxyP_x = \Delta_x\Sigma K_{xx} + \Delta_y\Sigma K_{xy} (33)

Py=ΔxΣKxy+ΔyΣKyyP_y = \Delta_x\Sigma K_{xy} + \Delta_y\Sigma K_{yy} (34)

Tp=ΔθJpT_p = \Delta_\theta J_p (35)

Where Jp=Σx2Kyy+Σy2Kxx−2ΣxyKxy+ΣJJ_p = \Sigma x^2K_{yy} + \Sigma y^2K_{xx} - 2\Sigma xyK_{xy} + \Sigma J (36)

The solution for the center of rigidity as defined in Equation 31 and 32 can be found if any set of trial coordinates are taken (x1,y1)(x_1 , y_1) with distances xˉ\bar{x} and yˉ\bar{y} to the center of rigidity. From Figure 3,

x=x1−xˉx = x_1 - \bar{x} (37)

y=y1−yˉy = y_1 - \bar{y} (38)

Figure 3: Center of Rigidity Trial Coordinates

Substituting Equations 37 and 38 into Equations 31 and 32:

Σ(x1−xˉ)Kxy−Σ(y1−yˉ)Kxx=0\Sigma (x_1 - \bar{x})K_{xy} - \Sigma (y_1 - \bar{y})K_{xx} = 0 (39)

Σ(x1−xˉ)Kyy−Σ(y1−yˉ)Kxy=0\Sigma (x_1 - \bar{x})K_{yy} - \Sigma (y_1 - \bar{y})K_{xy} = 0 (40)

By expanding and rearranging Equations 39 and 40, and noting that xˉ\bar{x} and yˉ\bar{y} (the coordinates of the center of rigidity) are constants, we obtain:

yˉΣKxx−xˉΣKxy=Σy1Kxx−Σx1Kxy\bar{y} \Sigma K_{xx} - \bar{x} \Sigma K_{xy} = \Sigma y_1 K_{xx} - \Sigma x_1 K_{xy} (41)

yˉΣKxy−xˉΣKyy=Σy1Kxy−Σx1Kyy\bar{y} \Sigma K_{xy} - \bar{x} \Sigma K_{yy} = \Sigma y_1 K_{xy} - \Sigma x_1 K_{yy} (42)

To solve this system of simultaneous equations for xˉ\bar{x} and yˉ\bar{y}, several approaches are possible. One common method is substitution, where one equation is rearranged to isolate a variable and then substituted into the other.

Equation 42 can be rearranged to express xˉ\bar{x} explicitly:

xˉ=yˉ∑Kxy−∑y1Kxy+∑x1Kyy∑Kyy\boxed{ \bar{x} = \frac{\bar{y} \sum K_{xy} - \sum y_1 K_{xy} + \sum x_1 K_{yy}}{\sum K_{yy}} } (43)

The resulting expression for xˉ\bar{x} can then be substituted into Equation 41, allowing the system to be solved explicitly for yˉ\bar{y}, as follows:

yˉ=∑y1Kxx−∑x1Kxy+∑x1Kyy⋅∑Kxy−∑y1Kxy⋅∑Kxy∑Kyy∑Kxx−(∑Kxy)2∑Kyy\boxed{ \bar{y} = \frac{ \sum y_1 K_{xx} - \sum x_1 K_{xy} + \frac{ \sum x_1 K_{yy} \cdot \sum K_{xy} - \sum y_1 K_{xy} \cdot \sum K_{xy} }{ \sum K_{yy} } }{ \sum K_{xx} - \frac{(\sum K_{xy})^2}{\sum K_{yy}} } } (44)

Final Solution

The solution for element global forces FxF_x and FyF_y and local shears VxV_x and VyV_y acting on any resisting element is then found as follows:

  1. Compute the local and global stiffness matrices [k]local[k]_{local} and [K][K] for each element from Equations 7 and 9.

  2. Locate the center of rigidity from Equations 43 and 44.

  3. Assemble the rigid diaphragm global stiffness matrix and compute displacements Δx,Δy,Δθ\Delta_x, \Delta_y, \Delta_\theta from Equation 30.

  4. Solve for element forces in the global system from Equation 23.

  5. Transform the element global forces to local shears VxV_x and VyV_y from Equation 10.

Orthogonal Lateral Force Resisting Systems

For orthogonal lateral force resisting systems, the problem simplifies significantly. Kxy=0K_{xy}=0, and the preceding equations reduce to a standard set of equations which may be familiar from manual or spreadsheet-based rigid diaphragm analyses.

Equations 43 and 44 for the coordinates of the center of rigidity reduce to:

xˉ=∑x1Kyy∑Kyy\bar{x} = \frac{\sum x_1 K_{yy}}{\sum K_{yy}} (45)

yˉ=∑y1Kxx∑Kxx\bar{y} = \frac{ \sum y_1 K_{xx} }{ \sum K_{xx} } (46)

Similarly, Equation 30 for the diaphragm displacement simplifies to:

Δx=PxΣKxx\Delta_x = \frac{P_x}{\Sigma K_{xx}} (47)

Δy=PyΣKyy\Delta_y = \frac{P_y}{\Sigma K_{yy}} (48)

Δθ=TpJp\Delta_\theta = \frac{T_p}{J_p} (49)

Finally, Equation 23 describing individual element forces acting on the diaphragm simplifies further, and substituting the results from Equations 47, 48, and 49 into this expression yields the final form of the solution.

Fx=ΔxKxx+Δθ(−yKxx)=PxKxxΣKxx−Tp(yKxx)JpF_x = \Delta_x K_{xx} + \Delta_\theta (-yK_{xx}) = \frac{P_x K_{xx}}{\Sigma K_{xx}} - \frac{T_p (yK_{xx})}{J_p} (50)

Fy=ΔyKyy+Δθ(xKyy)=PyKyyΣKyy+Tp(xKyy)JpF_y = \Delta_y K_{yy} + \Delta_\theta (xK_{yy}) = \frac{P_y K_{yy}}{\Sigma K_{yy}} + \frac{T_p (xK_{yy})}{J_p} (51)

Review

A design approach was presented which allows for the distribution of lateral loads in structures with rigid diaphragms and crosswalls and/or frame systems of any orientation. Required stiffness coefficients were found by inverting the flexibility matrix of the lateral force resisting system. The analysis presented herein for a one-story structure can be easily extended to multi-level structure where the center of gravity and center of rigidity are the resultants of the centers of all the levels above the level of analysis.

For a detailed worked example using this approach, please see our verification example — it includes calculation details, references to design provisions, and step-by-step results for easy checking.

Notations

AA = Cross-sectional area

[a]local[a]_{local} = Element local flexibility matrix

bb = Width of wall element

EbE_b = Modulus of elasticity

EvE_v = Shear modulus

FF = Force

Fx,Fy,FzF_x, F_y, F_z = Force in the global 'x', 'y', or 'z' direction

[F][F] = Element global force matrix

[f]local[f]_{local} = Element local force matrix

hh = Element height

II = Moment of inertia

I1,I2I_1,I_2 = Minimum and maximum moment of inertia

Ixx,IyyI_{xx}, I_{yy} = Moment of inertia about local 'x' or 'y' axis (∫Ax2∙da\int Ax^2\bullet da)

IxyI_{xy} = Moment of inertia about x-y axis (∫Axy∙da\int Axy\bullet da)

JJ = Rotational stiffness

KK = Stiffness

KijK_{ij} = Element stiffness along local 'i' in response to a unit displacement along local 'j'

[K][K] = Element global stiffness matrix

[k]local[k]_{local} = Element local stiffness matrix

MM = Moment

MpM_p = Torsional moment acting on resisting element

Mx,My,MzM_x, M_y, M_z = Moment about the global 'x', 'y', or 'z' axis

PP = Applied lateral load

Px,Py,PzP_x, P_y, P_z = Applied lateral load in the global 'x', 'y', or 'z' direction

QQ = Statical moment of area above plane of desired shear flow

TpT_p = Diaphragm torsional moment

[T][T] = Rotation matrix

X,Y,ZX, Y, Z = Coordinate axes

x,y,zx, y, z = Distance from resisting element to center of rigidity

x1,y1,z1x_1, y_1, z_1 = Distance from resisting element to origin

xˉ,yˉ\bar{ x }, \bar{ y } = Distance from the center of rigidity to origin

β\beta = Shear correction factor for cross-sectional shape of the element

δ\delta = Element total displacement

δf\delta_f = Element displacement due to flexure

δv\delta_v = Element displacement due to shear

δij\delta_{ij} = Element displacement along local 'i' in response to a unit force along local 'j'

Δx,Δy,Δz\Delta_x, \Delta_y, \Delta_z = Displacement of the rigid diaphragm in the global 'x', 'y', or 'z' direction

Δθ\Delta_\theta = Angle of rotation of the rigid diaphragm about the center of rigidity

θ\theta = Angle of rotation measured from the global x-axis to the element’s local x-axis

Last updated

Was this helpful?