Deflection in Masonry Columns
Why the Masonry Column module reports deflections using gross rather than cracked section properties.
Why does the Masonry Column module report deflections calculated using gross section properties (rather than cracked section properties)?
Short answer: TMS 402-22 does not explicitly require using cracked-section properties for deflection of reinforced masonry columns; it is largely silent on a detailed cracked vs. gross stiffness model for column deflection. In practice, the code framework implies elastic (uncracked / effective) stiffness unless second-order analysis or rational methods justify otherwise, with additional guidance coming from commentary and general masonry design practice rather than a prescriptive clause.
What TMS 402-22 actually provides
TMS 402 is written as a minimum design code covering strength and serviceability, but it intentionally avoids prescribing detailed analysis models for stiffness in many cases (Accuris Standards Store).
For columns specifically:
The code addresses axial load, flexure, and slenderness (P–Δ effects).
It requires accounting for second-order effects when slenderness is significant.
It relies on modulus of elasticity (Em)–based stiffness in analysis.
However:
There is no explicit clause stating “use cracked section properties” for deflection of masonry columns.
Nor is there a direct requirement to use gross section properties.
Implied stiffness model in TMS 402
From how the code is structured:
1. Elastic stiffness basis
Masonry analysis in TMS 402 is fundamentally elastic-based (Em·I) for service-level behavior.
Section properties used for stiffness are typically gross or effective (uncracked) section properties unless a refined analysis is performed.
This aligns with general masonry guidance:
Average (uncracked) section properties → used for elastic stiffness
Cracked/effective properties → used only when explicitly modeling inelastic response or for refined deflection estimates (CMHA)
2. Second-order (slenderness) effects
For columns, deflection is primarily handled indirectly through:
moment magnification or
second-order analysis
These provisions are based on member stiffness (EI), but again the code does not redefine I as cracked.
Commentary / engineering interpretation
The TMS 402-22 Commentary (non-mandatory) is where intent is clarified:
Masonry is brittle in tension, so cracking can occur.
However, for columns under dominant axial compression, flexural cracking is often limited.
Therefore, gross or effective section properties are typically acceptable for column stiffness, especially for:
compression-controlled sections
members with low tension demand
Cracked-section modeling is generally:
not required by code, and
only used when performing advanced analysis or when flexural tension governs.
Practical design takeaway
For reinforced concrete masonry columns under TMS 402-22:
Default / code-consistent approach
Use gross (or effective uncracked) section properties for stiffness (EI)
Apply slenderness / second-order provisions as required
When cracked properties may be used (engineering judgment)
Significant bending with tensile cracking
Detailed deflection predictions (serviceability-critical elements)
Nonlinear or refined analysis
What the code does NOT do
It does not mandate cracked inertia (Icr) like ACI 318 does for RC beams/columns in deflection checks.
Bottom line
TMS 402-22 does not explicitly require cracked section properties for deflection of reinforced masonry columns.
The code framework implies use of gross (elastic) section stiffness, with cracked-section analysis being optional and based on engineering judgment rather than a prescriptive requirement.
Last updated
Was this helpful?

